Re: RE: Emulators and Standards; Multimedia Policy Manuals

[ Home ][ Thread ][ Subject ][ Author ][ Date ]
Robert Spindler
Fri, 20 Feb 1998 10:49:02 -0700


Assuming that the "Music for Airports" is of such importance it is
deemed archival, I think we actually collect both the score and the
digital audio output. We would acquire and attempt to preserve the
digital audio output, possibly through reformatting and/or migration
because the performance of the music (particularly if directed by the
composer) has aspects that are not conveyed through the score - My
impression is that there is always some director's
discretion/interpretation applied to performance that makes the sound
recording actually a different "document" than the score! (I moonlight
as an acoustic blues musician so I'm not totally out of my element here,
although I'm sure Brian would have alot more to say here!) Should the
digital recording fail at least we have the score so the entire creative
product is not lost. But if the archivist is the transcriber of the
score, there may may be audible elements attributable to the composer in
the performance version that cannot be conveyed through a score and
would be lost if the digital recording is lost....

One other comment I would make regarding the "intelligent" archivist is
that although I have some sense of the issues surrounding documentation
and preservation I don't really have the skills to extract and preserve
algorithms, so I might not qualify for the "intelligent" attribute. I
think the key here is not individuals working alone but partnerships of
people that bring the range of necessary skills to the digital
preservation table!
Rob Spindler, Head
Dept. of Archives and Manuscripts
Arizona State University Libraries, Box 871006 Tempe, AZ 85287

> -----Original Message-----
>
> Sent: Friday, February 20, 1998 9:50 AM
>
> Subject: Re: Emulato rs and Standards; Multimedia Policy Manuals
>
> As the name implies, these are multiple media.
> New ones keep emerging, so standards keep changing.
> One enters the "plug-in" world where a work of art
> cannot be seen without some obscure new subroutine.
>
> But all god's chillun got algorithms.
> I keep thinking about "Music for Airports."
> Transcribers found a method to Eno's madness
> and scored for orchestra what had once been bits of tape.
> Of course, music, like math, makes the problem easier,
> but as Stewart says, "Let's solve the easy problems first."
>
> Consider music as an intelligent archivist challenge.
> One archivist goes off with a digitizer and reduces
> "Music for Airports" to bits of spectral sound. Another
> sits down, listens to the music and writes a score.
>
> Which goes into
> Dept. of Archives and Manuscripts
> Arizona State University Libraries, Rob?
>
> Which one satisfies the composer, Brian?
>
> Tom Ditto


  • Reply: : "Re: RE: Emulators and Standards; Multimedia Policy Manuals"